newsarama.com
advertisement
What Is a Planet? Debate Forces New Definition
Three Extrasolar Planets Found By Telescope Down Under
Search for Another Earth Quietly Underway
Future Missions to Search for Earth-like Planets
Astronomers Find Two Unusual Planetary Systems
By Dan Falk
Special to SPACE.com
posted: 09:52 pm ET
09 January 2001

planet_systems_010110

SAN DIEGO -- The world's most prolific planet-hunting team has done it again, this time announcing the discovery of what may be the weirdest solar systems observed so far -- one harboring two humongous planets and another with planets in synchronized orbits.

Geoff Marcy of the University of California in Berkeley, with Paul Butler, Debra Fischer and other colleagues, announced on Tuesday the two unique planetary systems as part of their ongoing survey of nearby stars -- systems that appear to challenge current theories of how planetary systems form.

"We thought we understood the lay of the land in terms of planetary systems," said Marcy, whose team has found more than half of the 50-plus extrasolar planets discovered so far. "We were becoming a bit cocky -- we thought we knew the full diversity of planets."

But the two new systems -- known as HD168443 and Gliese 876, "depart quite dramatically from our expectations."

The team presented its findings Tuesday at the winter meeting of the American Astronomical Society in San Diego.

A 'whopper'

The first system, known as HD168443, contains a massive planet more than seven times the size of Jupiter, along with an even larger planet-like object dubbed a "whopper" by Marcy and his team. This second, outer object weighs in with 17 times the mass of Jupiter and orbits about three Astronomical Units (about 270 million miles) from its host star.

"Frankly, that one is so massive, we don't even know if the term 'planet' is appropriate for it," Marcy said in an interview. But he added that it would be presumptuous to call the object a brown dwarf because it most likely formed in a manner similar to that of the giant planets in our own solar system.

The "whopper" and its companion likely formed as an accretion disk swirled around the host star, Marcy said, and in the process "somehow, gobbling up so much mass that they became humongous planets."

HD168443 is located about 123 light-years from Earth in the direction of the southern constellation Serpens.

The star's 17-Jupiter-mass companion "is about twice as massive as anything we've previously seen," said Paul Butler of the Carnegie Institution in Washington, D.C. But he agrees with Marcy that it makes more sense to call the object a planet rather than a star.

"To say it's a brown dwarf is just sweeping all of the mysteries under the rug," he said.

The two large planet-like objects "presumably both formed in a disk around the star, as conventional planets do. But the fact that they're so massive suggests perhaps some new mechanism."

Computer simulations suggest that multiple-planet systems may be common -- however, most models suggest that having two ultra-giant planets, especially in such tight orbits about their host star, would be rare. The two systems "remind us of the extraordinary diversity of planetary systems," Butler said.

A system with resonance

The second system, known as Gliese 876, contains two Jupiter-sized planets orbiting a red dwarf star. It lies some 15 light-years from Earth in the direction of the constellation Aquarius. The system is unusual because its two planets "resonate" with orbital periods of 30 days and 60 days. It is the first planetary system known to display a two-to-one resonance. (In our own solar system, the planets Neptune and Pluto display a three-to-two resonance.) Team member Debra Fischer of Berkeley compared the resonating planets to a stringed musical instrument that can play a single note with two "harmonics."

The two solar systems had been known for several years, but had each been thought to contain just a single planet. New observations revealed that each had a second planet-like companion as well. Marcy's team used data from the Keck 1 telescope in Hawaii and the Lick Observatory telescope in California, relying on spectroscopic observations to look for the gravitational "wobble" effect that unseen companion bodies can have on the motion of their host stars.

Shaking down models for planetary formation

Marcy says that it is now up to theoreticians to revise their models of planetary formation to explain these new, peculiar solar systems.

"They have to explain to us why planets have the diversity of characteristics that they have," said Marcy, "why they have masses up to 15 or 20 Jupiter masses, orbits that are eccentric and resonant planets -- planets with orbital periods that are in synch with each other. So the ball is clearly in the theorists' court right now."

Other Earths out there?

He also said the observations are a positive sign that Earth-sized planets may be out there, awaiting detection.

"I would say these discoveries represent a thumb's up for terrestrial planets," Marcy said. "We're finding more and more planetary systems, a great diversity of planets. The bottom line is, stars are typically attended by a complement of planets, some of which are probably Earth-sized."

Some observers were more critical of that idea, however, saying that the gravitational tug from numerous giant planets could lead to solar systems which are unlikely to harbor Earth-like siblings.

Systems like those announced by Marcy's team on Tuesday "probably won't be forming many terrestrial planets," said Hal Levison of the Southwest Research Institute in Boulder, Colorado.

"And if they are, they're probably closer to their sun than the habitable zone [the distance range from the star in which liquid water could be sustained on a planet's surface]."

Marcy's team also includes Steve Vogt of Santa Cruz and Jack Lissauer of the NASA Ames Research Center in California. The findings have been submitted to the Astrophysical Journal for publication.

The research is part of an ongoing to project to search for planets around 1,100 stars within 300 light-years of Earth. The work is supported by NASA, the National Science Foundation and Sun Microsystems.

 

New Starry Night Enthusiast Version 6
$79.95
Explore More



















Site Map | News | SpaceFlight | Science | Technology | Entertainment | SpaceViews | NightSky | Ad Astra | SETI | Hot Topics
Image Galleries | Videos | Reader Favorites | Image of the Day | Amazing Images | Wallpapers | Games | Community
about us | FREE Email Newsletter | message boards | register at SPACE.com | contact us | advertise | terms of service | privacy statement
DMCA/Copyright
  What is This?