If only for Buzz Aldrin "Dancing with the Stars" was more about the stars than dancing. Then he may have very well topped the judges' scoreboard at the end of Monday's night's two-hour show premiere on ABC.
"I remember sitting at home in England watching you walking on the Moon and being amazed, not only at the technology, but the braveness of you guys for going up there for the first time," gushed judge Len Goodman after watching Aldrin (opens in new tab) with his partner Ashly Costa dance the Cha-cha-cha to The Spinners' song "Cupid/I've Loved You For A Long Time."
"How can I possibly criticize a hero and a legend?" asked fellow judge Bruno Tonioli.
"You know what is great about this show (opens in new tab) is that it inspires people at home to get out and do things that they might be afraid of," added judge Carrie Ann Inaba. "You inspired a ton of people tonight."
Alas, inspiration aside, Aldrin's routine left the judges less than impressed.
"I want to commend you for your bravery for coming out tonight," Goodman, a British professional ballroom dancer, remarked. "Unfortunately, I cannot give marks for bravery, just the dancing, and that wasn't too good unfortunately."
"You did a cha-cha-cha, it was actually a cha-cha-cha [but] it looked like you still had your moon boots on," said Italian choreographer Tonioli. "Let's say it is going to get better next week."
Tonioli and Inaba gave Aldrin a score of 5 each. Goodman awarded the moonwalker a 4, giving Aldrin 14 points out of a possible 30, which was the lowest score of the evening.
Pussycat Dolls lead singer Nicole Scherzinger scored the highest with 25 points, with gold medal figure skater Evan Lysacek close behind at 23 points.
A moonwalker moonwalks
That's not to say everyone agreed with the judges.
Even before he danced, Aldrin was cheered on by a videotaped message by fellow astronauts aboard the International Space Station.
"Buzz, we know you're an original moonwalker but can you still do this move?" said Expedition 23 flight engineer T.J. Creamer as he performed a weightless back flip. "All the best from the International Space Station!"
The studio audience applauded the video from space and Aldrin's dance moves.
A cutaway shot revealed that among those cheering was actor Tim Allen. Though it wasn't stated, Allen voices the animated "Toy Story" astronaut Buzz Lightyear, who was named after the real moonwalker-turned-dancer.
Aldrin also drew the attention of those watching the live broadcast on TV, as became evident when his name began trending on the Twitter online social network.
Many of the 140-character notes joked about Aldrin doing the moonwalk, the dance move made famous by the late singer Michael Jackson.
The joke didn't escape the show's producers either.
At the start of the broadcast, host Tom Bergeron referred to Aldrin as "an American icon who moonwalked years before anyone did it to music."
For his part, Aldrin didn't disappoint: he did indeed perform the moonwalk, though he gave it his own style.
"Was that a little moonwalk I saw?" judge Inaba asked the astronaut.
"That was," confirmed Aldrin with a smile.
Down but not out
Aldrin will have another chance to improve his score when he dances again next week. The scores from the first two weeks will then be combined.
The judges' scores however are not the only input that will decide if Aldrin goes on in the competition. Viewers vote for their favorites by phone, text message and on ABC's website.
The contestant with the lowest combined score from the judges and viewer votes is eliminated during the "results show," a separate broadcast on the Tuesday following the competition night.
Costa, a professional dancer who performed on "Dancing with the Stars" first three seasons, described what it was that concerned her about Aldrin during a taped segment of Monday's live show.
"For an 80-year-old, Buzz is in great shape physically. I'm more concerned about him memorizing all these steps."
Aldrin, who appeared to be counting his steps out loud as he danced, admitted it was a difficulty.
"It used to take two times to remember something, now it?s 20," he said, but warned about counting him out.
"People may have a tendency to underestimate me," said Aldrin, "but watch out, here I come."
Visit collectSPACE.com throughout Buzz Aldrin's time on "Dancing with the Stars" for the latest episode updates and photographs.
Though phone and text voting closed 30 minutes after the end of the show, voting continues on ABC's "Dancing with the Stars" website through noon (Eastern time) March 23. The next broadcast will air live Monday, March 29 at 8pm EDT/7pm CDT on the ABC Television Network.
Copyright 2010 collectSPACE.com. All rights reserved.