Ad Astra OnlineLiveScience.com HomepageStarryNight.comtelescope.com
  SEARCH:

advertisement


The Humans Were Flat but the Cheela Were Charming in 'Dragon's Egg'
By Chris Aylott

Associate Editor

posted: 06:34 pm ET
30 March 2000

The Humans are Flat and the Cheela are Charming in "Dragon's Egg"  
Twenty years after its publication, Dragon's Egg has become a minor classic of science fiction -- one that shows off both the best and worst elements of hard SF. In physicist Robert L. Forward's tale of life on a neutron star, the ideas definitely come first.

Forward was inspired by an Astronomy article by Frank Drake, and developed the idea as background for a possible Larry Niven novel. Niven considered collaborating with Forward on the book, but ultimately encouraged him to write it himself.


   More Stories

Robert Forward: From Dragon's Eggs to Space Tethers


'Dragon's Egg': Robert Forward Remembers


A Strong Mesh and a Laser: Robert Forward on Tethers


Star Trek: Voyager - 'Blink of an Eye'

   Related Links

Forward Unlimited


Tethers Unlimited

After a couple of drafts and a detailed critique from ace SF editor Lester del Rey, Del Rey Books bought the novel and published it in 1980. It won solid reviews from the likes of Publisher's Weekly and the Washington Post, spent years in print, and recently returned as part of Del Rey's Impact line of SF classics.

Heavy stranger in our neighborhood

The "Dragon's Egg" is a neutron star passing through the outer reaches of the solar system. Despite having nearly half the mass of our sun, it's too distant to be any threat to 21st-Century humanity -- it's merely a scientific curiosity.

When an exploration team arrives, however, they are astonished to discover life on the star's surface. The cheela are slug-like creatures about the size of a sesame seed, but their incredible density means that their mass and physical complexity is roughly equivalent to that of a 200-pound human.

The cheela's high-energy environment also means that they live about a million times as fast as humans. Their "day" passes in a fifth of a second and a human minute seems as long as a year to a cheela.

Forward makes the most of the complications involved in making contact with such a fast-moving species. Communication proves difficult but not impossible, and creative solutions to the time problem provide some of the best moments in the book.

Life among the cheela

Where the book really stands out, however, is in the sections devoted to the lives of Forward's alien cheela.

Forward follows their civilization from the discovery of agriculture -- which occurs on Sunday, May 22, 2050, in Earth chronology -- to the beginning of their space age less than an Earth-month later. We see their grand journeys across the star's 60-kilometer circumference, the invention of mathematics, and the birth of religion and astronomy.

In the wrong hands, the cheela development would be cute or anthropomorphic. Forward almost always avoids those traps.

Cheela behavior sometimes parallels human behavior, but only when the basic motivation -- food or survival, for instance -- is almost identical. Forward portrays his aliens' other behaviors are logical but inhuman, driven as they are by completely different conditions.

Who needs humans?

While they may not be human, the cheela always seem like people. The characters share a common questing spirit, but they stand out as individuals.

The same can't be said for the human characters. They're perfect representatives of the cardboard scientists typical of hard SF.

Despite a lively prologue, the early scenes among the humans are painfully dull, and could probably have been skipped entirely -- especially since Forward has included a "technical appendix" that covers the same information and is more fun to read.

The humans become more interesting when they finally mount an expedition to Dragon's Egg, but that's mostly thanks to their interaction with the cheela.

... Not hard SF!

It's a flaw that makes the novel particularly representative of its sub-genre. Hard science fiction is a game of asking "what if?" and the cheela are the heart of the question driving Dragon's Egg.

It's an approach that inevitably limits the appeal of hard SF -- most people would rather read about people than ideas or even strange alien mindsets. Still, the cheela are just as charming today as they were twenty years ago.

If they're fascinating, it's because Forward is fascinated by them, and had the writing skill to communicate his interest to his readers. If the human scientists are dull, it's because they're simply a means to the end of understanding the aliens.


What do you think? Send your comments to the editor.


     about us | FREE Email Newsletter | message boards | register at SPACE.com | contact us | advertise with us | terms & conditions | privacy policy      DMCA/Copyright

     © Imaginova Corp. All rights reserved.