DENVER,
Colorado – A strong core of believers continue to tout the
notion of frequent alien visitors to Earth — UFOs — although this view is
largely dismissed by skeptical, mainstream researchers.
But UFOlogists
come in two flavors: Those who spend money to investigate the possibility, and
those who simply aim to make money off the whole concept.
All this
was discussed here last month at the 40th Annual International UFO
Symposium, staged by the Mutual UFO Network, Inc., or MUFON, based in Fort Collins, Colorado. The symposium subtitle: "Dawn of a new era in UFO research."
A few
lecture topics by noted speakers tell the story, from reflections of an old UFO
chaser to dramatic changes in trace/landing events, as well as highlights from
a 20-year study of Canadian sightings and even a talk on engaging a skeptic
about UFOs.
Pseudoscientific
A long-time
veteran of UFOlogy is Stanton Friedman, a nuclear physicist and lecturer on
incoming ET traffic. And he is resolute.
"If one
makes an appropriately objective and careful examination of the pro and anti-UFO
arguments, one finds that the evidence is overwhelming that Earth is being
visited by intelligently controlled vehicles of extraterrestrial origin and
that only pseudoscientific arguments of a vocal but small group of debunkers
stand in the way of reaching that conclusion, along with a fear of ridicule for
being logical," Friedman explained.
Friedman's
advice to UFO devotes: "Take courage. I have had only 11 hecklers at more than
700 lectures...and two of them were drunk."
Decades of
UFO study are under the belt of Frank Salisbury, emeritus professor of plant
physiology at Utah State University in Logan.
Given all
that research, Salisbury's bottom line is that UFOs "are both real and
important...whatever they are!" In the meantime, he added, don't discount a
nearby parallel
universe or a worm hole as ingredients in the saga.
Salisbury's sense is that there are
intelligences behind the UFOs. And he served up a take-home message too.
"They want
to be seen by a few of us, influencing us in some way unknown to us. So what
are they trying to achieve with their displays? Darned if I know! For one
thing, they might simply want to keep us confused. With me, they have
succeeded."
Getting
to the truth
As for
what's hot in UFO research, James Carrion, MUFON
International Director, said the organization has initiated a strategic
relationship with Las Vegas-based hotel mogul and space module entrepreneur,
Robert Bigelow.
In the
works since April, Bigelow is footing the bill on operational expenses so MUFON
investigators can pay attention to high priority cases, Carrion said, "and not
go chasing lights in the sky."
Trained
MUFON specialists can now be rapidly deployed, sent to sighting areas to gather
data, even send physical evidence to a lab "while it's fresh, before other
folks try to horde it," Carrion said. "In other words, really pay attention to
what we should be paying attention to."
Carrion is
frank regarding today's state of UFOlogy. He leaves no doubt that there are
hucksters – not just, perhaps, aliens—among us.
"There are
those of us in MUFON who want to solve the mystery. There are those other folks
out there that want to
perpetuate the mystery. There is this cottage industry out there. This is
their employment and a way to make a buck," Carrion pointed out. "They have no
desire to really get to the truth."
But for
Carrion, the truth is out there.
"I think
there's a core phenomenon. But we have to whittle away at it," Carrion told SPACE.com.
One specific research track that he dubs "forensic history" is following the
role of the U.S. Government in the UFO field.
"There's an
indelible fingerprint out there that shows what the patterns of activity have
been. It'll take some research," Carrion said. The Internet has proven to be a
powerful tool, he said, enabling the gathering of UFO-related information
instantaneously and to help corroborate items of interest.
"In my
opinion, UFOlogists have only scratched the surface of potential research on
the role of the Government in the UFO field, especially as it relates to
counter-intelligence, code breaking, psychological warfare, and Cold War
operations."
Evidentiary
rules
Taking part
in the MUFON meeting was Jeffrey Bennett, scientist and author of "Beyond
UFOs - The Search for Extraterrestrial Life and Its Astonishing Implications
for Our Future."
Admittedly
on the agenda as a "token skeptic," Bennett's view is that UFO advocates are
best served by "assigning plausibility" to the conviction by hard core
believers that Earth is on the receiving end of alien travelers.
"They think
they've got evidence. But for me, it's not strong enough yet," Bennett told SPACE.com.
One complaint he heard at the MUFON gathering was that mainstream scientists
won't fund UFO research.
"But it's
the way science works," Bennett counters. The kind of proof presented has not
met the standards of scientific scrutiny, he added, "and if it ever does,
they'll get their funding."
Others
too dismissive?
For the
most part, UFO activists are using a different set of evidentiary rules,
Bennett said. "We've got our reasons why we like our set of
rules in science, because it has been successful. It has allowed a lot of
progress."
Bennett
spotlights the technological level necessary to trek here from other stars.
Then toss in the scale of the universe...the scale of time too. Views generated
by "Star Wars" and "Star Trek" have invaded popular
culture, so much so, that speeding through the cosmos appears to be a piece of
cake.
"In fact,
the technology is so incredible that it makes almost all the UFO claims look
kind of silly," Bennett said. For instance, scooting across a humungous stretch
of space and time to pile drive your craft into Roswell, New Mexico...that's
more a stretch in plausibility, he observed.
All that
being said, Bennett feels that sometimes the scientific community is far too
dismissive of those that witness occurrences chalked up as UFOs.
"We can
wish that everybody uses the same standards of evidence. But there's nothing
wrong with them as human beings for not doing so. Leave them alone. Let them
keep their interests up. Use that opportunity to educate them a little bit
along the way...then that's good," Bennett concluded.
Whatever
your UFO in-take is, be it a real deal belief, fantasy folk lore and/or a raw
form of pulp fiction, one can't leave a MUFON convocation without bringing to
mind a Bob Dylan lyric: "Something is happening here...but you don't know what it
is."
Leonard
David has been reporting on the space industry for more than four decades. He
is past editor-in-chief of the National Space Society's Ad Astra and Space
World magazines and has written for SPACE.com since 1999.