CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) --
Workers may have accidentally cut or crushed the section of foam that broke off
Discovery's fuel tank during its launch two months ago--a mishap that threatened
the safety of the astronauts and grounded the shuttle fleet.
That is the leading theory
for the cause behind the disturbing loss of foam insulation that cast a cloud
over NASA's return to space, said Wayne Hale, the newly appointed manager of
the space shuttle program.
In a wide-ranging interview
with The Associated Press on Tuesday, Hale said the shuttle will not fly again
until the foam insulation problem is resolved _ no sooner than spring.
He also said repair work has
been set back because of hurricanes Katrina and Rita. The storms dealt ''a
severe blow'' to resuming shuttle flights and caused NASA to lose three months
of work, he said.
In a memo soon after Katrina
slammed two shuttle facilities on the Gulf Coast, Hale speculated that the
space shuttles might be grounded until fall 2006. He has since backed off that
pessimistic view and noted that progress has been made in understanding the
foam problem and getting the Michoud Assembly Facility in New Orleans--which
manufactures the tanks--back into limited operation.
"We're working a spring
kind of launch date, but we haven't established one," he said. May is the
earliest, most likely target.
To NASA's horror, a 1-pound,
3-foot chunk of insulating foam peeled away from Discovery's external fuel tank
during liftoff in late July. It was the same kind of problem that doomed Columbia in 2003, and occurred despite 2 1/2 years of improvements and assurances that
this was the safest tank ever built.
What probably happened is
that during modifications to the tank at Michoud, technicians inadvertently
damaged the section that ended up coming off, while working on nearby areas,
Hale said. "This foam, which normally is not touched after it's applied,
clearly was touched," he said.
Workers using plastic knives
to remove nearby foam may have made small cuts in the section that tore away,
allowing air to condense in the crevices against the tank, full of super-cold
fuel, Hale said. Another possibility, he said, is that workers leaned against
the piece of foam that broke off, and fractured it. Yet another theory is that the
foam cracked because of normal thermal stresses.
A spokesman for Lockheed
Martin Corp., which builds the tanks at Michoud, said inadvertent worker damage
is one of the potential causes being investigated. "We're committed to
supporting NASA and the space shuttle program," spokesman Harry Wadsworth
said.
Engineers have more work to
do before confirming any of this, the shuttle manager said. A fuel tank that
finally arrived at Michoud this week from Cape Canaveral--a trip delayed by the
hurricanes--will be dissected for evidence of damage. The earliest that a
modified tank could be returned to Cape Canaveral is February, making a spring
launch a possibility, Hale said.
NASA has zeroed in on two
other problems during Discovery's flight that posed safety concerns for
re-entry:
A faulty gluing process
caused a couple of fabric strips to come loose and protrude from the shuttle's
belly. In a dramatic spacewalk--the first time an astronaut had ever ventured
beneath the shuttle's underside--Stephen Robinson removed them.
The installation method is
being improved and stronger testing is planned, said Steve Poulos, manager of
the orbiter project office.
A rip in a thermal blanket
hanging beneath a cockpit window was traced to poor stitching; thankfully, no
repairs were required in orbit. NASA is inspecting all 480 blankets on each
shuttle to make sure the stitches go all the way through the material.
As for the fuel tanks, NASA
will remove the foam section in question and, at least for the next few
flights, apply fresh foam using new and improved techniques.
This section of foam, the
so-called PAL ramp, is essentially a wind deflector, protecting cable trays and
pressurization lines running the length of the tank. Until Discovery's launch,
NASA did not think that area needed to be fixed.
Hale acknowledged the space
agency also still needs to improve its safety culture, a systemic problem that
contributed to the Columbia disaster and which persists in the minds of some
members of an oversight panel.
Hale, who served as deputy
shuttle program manager before being promoted two weeks ago, said he has taken
the scathing criticism from Discovery's problems to heart.
"I am committed ... to
making sure that we go into it eyes-wide-open with a good understanding of what
the risks are and not just brushing things aside," he said.