Comet Garradd Visible in Telescopes This Month, But What About Comet Elenin?

Comet Garradd will be visible in binoculars and small telescopes all through October in constellation Hercules.
Comet Garradd will be visible in binoculars and small telescopes all through October in constellation Hercules. (Image credit: Starry Night Software)

Although great comets like Halley and Hale-Bopp only fly close to the Earth a few times each century, there are always small comets in our cosmic neighborhood. This month, there are two to keep an eye on: comet Garradd and comet Elenin.

Comets are small bodies composed of rock and ice (water and carbon dioxide) that spend most of the time in the frozen outer reaches of the solar system, in an area known as the Oort Cloud.

A few times every year, a comet gets knocked out of those distant reaches and pays a brief visit to the inner solar system. The sky map of comet Garradd here   shows its position across the sky this month.

As the sun heats a comet up, the object's ice turns to gas and frees the dust on its surface. Solar wind then drives this gas and dust away from the sun, causing a tail to form.

Because a comet's tail is driven by the solar wind, it always points away from the source of that wind, the sun. Although the solid body of a comet is very small — only a few miles in diameter — the tail can stretch thousands of miles into space. [Photos of Comet Elenin]

The changing comet Elenin

Comet tails are little more than empty space, but their faint glow creates one of the most beautiful sights in the sky. These tails are gossamer thin and very fragile, and can be easily disrupted by solar activity.

This happened over the past few weeks to another small comet, comet Elenin. This comet had the potential to be visible to the naked eye this week, but it received a double blow from the sun and seems to have disintegrated.

First, comet Elenin got hit by a coronal mass ejection, a dynamic event that unleashes a cloud of charged particles and knots of magnetic field, from the sun on Aug. 19. This caused the comet's material to disperse and its brightness to drop.

Then on Sept. 10, comet Elenin reached its closest approach to the sun, and that seems to put the final nail in its coffin. The small comet failed to materialize last week in camera views from NASA's sun-watching Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO), so it seems very unlikely that there will be anything to see this week, when there was hope that it would be visible as a morning comet.

Comet Elenin has been a target for conspiracy theorists, who have suggested that the comet is a brown dwarf or the mysterious and destructive planet Nibiru. As a result, Elenin has been blamed for earthquakes and tsunamis and other strange occurrences.

But alas, comet Elenin is just a small, dim comet that poses no risk to Earth, and Nibiru does not exist at all, NASA scientists have said.

Comet Garradd's time to shine

But for skywatchers, while Elenin may be a no-show, there will be another comet visible to those willing to hunt it down with binoculars: comet Garradd.

Comet Garradd was discovered by Australian astronomer Gordon Garradd two years ago. Because of its orbit, the comet has taken this long to make an evening appearance in our sky. [Best Close Encounters of the Comet Kind]

Last month, the comet traveled across the constellation Sagitta, having close encounters with two popular deep sky objects: the globular Messier 71 cluster and the Coathanger Cluster, which got its nickname because it looks like an upside down coat hanger.

This month, comet Garradd can be found between the keystone of the constellation Hercules and the two bright stars Rasalhague and Rasalgethi, the respective “heads” of two celestial strongmen: Ophiuchus and Hercules.

The sky map for this story shows Garradd nightly positions over the month of October; the label marks its position on Oct. 1. It will hover in brightness between magnitude 7.8 and magnitude 8, too dim to be seen with the naked eye, but easily detectable with binoculars or a small telescope. On the magnitude scale used by astronomers to measure an object's brightness in space, the higher the number, the dimmer the object appears.

Meanwhile, keep an eye out just before sunrise to see whether Comet Elenin has, by some chance, survived its close encounter with the sun. If it did survive, the comet should appear in the constellation of Leo this week, before moving through Cancer and into Gemini.

Editor's note: If you snap an amazing photo of comet Garradd, comet Elenin or any other skywatching target and would like to share the experience with for a possible story or photo gallery, please contact managing editor Tariq Malik at:

This article was provided to by Starry Night Education, the leader in space science curriculum solutions. Follow Starry Night on Twitter @StarryNightEdu.

Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions, night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at:

Geoff Gaherty
Starry Night Sky Columnist

Geoff Gaherty was's Night Sky columnist and in partnership with Starry Night software and a dedicated amateur astronomer who sought to share the wonders of the night sky with the world. Based in Canada, Geoff studied mathematics and physics at McGill University and earned a Ph.D. in anthropology from the University of Toronto, all while pursuing a passion for the night sky and serving as an astronomy communicator. He credited a partial solar eclipse observed in 1946 (at age 5) and his 1957 sighting of the Comet Arend-Roland as a teenager for sparking his interest in amateur astronomy. In 2008, Geoff won the Chant Medal from the Royal Astronomical Society of Canada, an award given to a Canadian amateur astronomer in recognition of their lifetime achievements. Sadly, Geoff passed away July 7, 2016 due to complications from a kidney transplant, but his legacy continues at Starry Night.