Recently, I've seen a bumper sticker that
states, "If you can read this, thank a teacher." Each year the first full week
in May is Teacher Appreciation Week. There's more than 3 million teachers in
elementary, middle and high school classrooms teaching about 46 million
children how to read, write, calculate, conduct experiments, observe the
universe, and grow up to be good citizens. That's a lot of people to thank, but
thanks are not enough.
By 2012, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS)
predicts that we will need about 18% more teachers than are in the classroom
now. The BLS notes that
"Currently, many school districts have difficulty hiring
qualified teachers in some subject areas--mathematics, science (especially
chemistry and physics), bilingual education, and foreign languages." Teaching
is a growth industry, but will schools be able to attract people to the
profession? In particular, will schools be able to attract those trained in
mathematics and physical sciences?
According the BSL, the annual median starting
salary for a teacher is just under $31,000 (2002). Compare that with the
$60,000 median salary of lawyers just 6 months after graduation, and the median
salary for all lawyers at over $90,000 (2002). According to the American
Federation of Teachers (AFT), one of two major teacher unions, the average
salary for all public school teachers of grades kindergarten through 12th was
$44,367 (2001-2002). That includes people who have taught for 35 years and are
at the top of the salary scale. One need not wonder about the apparent surplus
of lawyers, and the shortage of teachers.
Today, new science and mathematics teachers are
required to complete an academic major in the discipline they will teach. The
requirements of "No Child Left Behind" demand increased academic preparation of
teachers based on the need to improve pre-college education. I have no
complaint with higher standards.
My question is whether the teaching profession
will be able to attract the science and mathematics majors into pre-college
careers when one considers the simple economics of the situation. Individuals
who complete degrees in mathematics and sciences have other options. (All statistics from BSL, 2002 or 2003)
Career Annual Median Income (in thousands, rounded off)
|
K-12 Teacher
|
$44
|
|
Zoologist/Wildlife Biologist
|
$47
|
|
Environmental Scientist
|
$47
|
|
Chemist
|
$53
|
|
Computer Programmer
|
$60
|
|
Biochemist/biophysicist
|
$60
|
|
Environmental Engineer
|
$61
|
|
Geoscientist
|
$67
|
|
Chemical Engineer
|
$72
|
|
Mathematicians
|
$76
|
|
Physicist (BA/BS level)
|
$78
|
|
Astronomer (PhD level)
|
$82
|
|
Physicist (PhD level)
|
$95
|
The old argument that "teaching is a part-time
job" and so has a "part-time salary" does not hold up. Teachers are employed
185 to 200 days each year, not including school breaks during the academic
year. Many teachers move from the classroom to summer employment to pay the bills, or to coursework to sustain their teaching
credentials or licenses. There are no lazy days of summer for most teachers.
Most high school science teachers are trained in
biology, and find themselves teaching all of the sciences. Certainly, many are
competent to teach courses besides biology. High school physics, chemistry, and
earth science teachers that have discipline majors are rare. The lack of truly
qualified people is, in part, due to teaching salaries that are not competitive
with industry, research, and other government employment, plus working
conditions. Few scientists would expect to provide their own supplies, make due
with out-of-date texts, and old equipment. But, this is often the case in
science classrooms. We can't educate for the future without well-educated
teachers and proper materials and equipment. I believe that we need to raise
teacher salaries and provide them with the tools to teach.
If you read this, thank a teacher. If you are
still excited about exploring the universe from the realm of the atom to the
most distant galaxy, thank a science teacher. If you use mathematics in daily
life, thank a mathematics teacher. If
you enjoy your personal computer, your cell phone, your pace maker, etc., thank
the teachers who prepared all the scientists and engineers that work in technology.
But that's not enough. Next week, attend a
school board meeting and ask for better classroom support for science and
mathematics instruction. The week after, write a letter to your representative
in state government asking for better support for science and mathematics
education. Write and email your Congressional Representative and Senator asking
them to restore the education funding to the National Science Foundation that
supports science and mathematics education. It's been drastically cut over the
past two years.
Teachers work for us all, and they need
more than thanks. They need our support.