Fans generally agree that
the genius of George Lucas' Star Wars saga is how it takes an ancient story
formula that speaks to us on a gut level and turns it into a really cool,
contemporary science fiction masterpiece.
The saga is as deep as we
want it to be. For example, let's look at the grim case of Obi-Wan Kenobi,
one-time teacher of jedi knights.
While Anakin Skywalker is
as tragic a figure as any, Kenobi is the leading candidate to walk in the
footsteps of Sophocles' Oedipus Rex and other tragic heroes in the classical
sense.
 |
 |
 |  | More Stories |
|  |
 | |  |
 | |  |
 | |  |
 | |  |
 |  | Related Links |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
For those who are a little
rusty on their college lit, Sophocles' King Oedipus desperately seeks to
end a series of plagues that appear to stem from some unknown atrocity
committed in his kingdom. This is his fatal error or, in Greek dramatic
terms, hamartia.
In spite of dire warnings
from the blind prophet Tiresias, the king relentlessly pursues the source
of his country's woes until he discovers, horrifyingly, that the culprit
is himself -- the plagues were divine punishment for his unwittingly murder
of his father and marriage to his own mother.
Destroyed by guilt, Oedipus
gouges his own eyes out and exiles himself as penance for his overreaching
pride. He had defied the gods in wishing to put an end to their plagues,
and it is this hubris (defiance of the gods) that brought him to
ruin.
The sound of celebration
rings hollow to my ears
Wandering in the desert
We'll have to wait for future
installments to watch horrified as Kenobi's fatal error plunges the galaxy
into 20 years of fascist terror at the hands of Palpatine. Yet his hubris
and the nature of his self-inflicted punishment are already evident in
the original trilogy.
His pride is such that he
assumes responsibility for Anakin Skywalker's fall and feels that the least
he can do to make things up to Padmé – and the entire galaxy.
"I thought I could train
him as well as Master Yoda," laments the ghost of Obi-Wan Kenobi in The
Return of the Jedi, referring to his ill-fated apprentice. In the novelization,
he continues: "My pride had terrible consequences for the galaxy." Sophocles
himself could have written the lines to describe the scene when Oedipus
discovers the terrible truth behind the plagues that beset his kingdom.
Obi-Wan's penance, thankfully
not involving mutilation, is 20 dusty years alone in the desert of Tatooine.
The great sacrifice
Ultimately, he gives his
life to save Luke, the child in whom all hope resides.
So why didn't he raise Luke
himself, training him from infancy in the Jedi tradition? Perhaps he's
lost confidence in his teaching skills since his first and only pedagogical
experience, his abysmal failure with Anakin. Perhaps keeping Luke too close
by would be a danger to the boy if Vader ever caught up with him.
And perhaps he feels he
really deserves to live all alone as a crazy old hermit in a tiny hovel
in the middle of the scorching Jundland wastes.
Ironically, Obi-Wan's hubris
doesn't die with him. Even as a Force Ghost he continues to entertain the
notion that everything dreadful that happened in the galaxy was his own
fault. You'd think that by the time he sloughed off his material form and
fused with the Force he would understand that he has only been a pawn in
the Force's quest for balance.
Puppets of the Force
As of The Phantom Menace,
the Force is more than a vague, mysterious telekinetic potential. When
Qui-Gon Jinn suggests that "the will of the Force" led him to Anakin in
the course of his adventures, he adds a new dimension to the diffuse, mystic
logos
of the original trilogy, that Force that surrounded and bound us.
Now, suddenly, the Force
possesses conscious will, providence; it can even immaculately produce
children. It's a deity.
The question then arises,
as in all Greek tragedy, why the Force would punish its humble servant
Kenobi for the unwitting errors it predestined him to make. This is the
source of all pathos, the profound tragedy of humanoid existence,
the current of injustice that drags us all to our deaths, and the irony
that binds every spectator to the tragic hero. Kenobi, like everyone in
the saga, is a slave to destiny.
Master, it is too much
for me
In fact, it is still unclear
why the Jedi Council agrees to let him train the Chosen One.
Even though Yoda expresses
misgivings about training Anakin at all, no one seems to question the appropriateness
of assigning young, headstrong, reckless Obi-Wan Kenobi to the kid with
the biggest midichlorian count in history.
When a Jedi gives his word,
as Obi-Wan does when the dying Qui-Gon exhorts him to train the boy, is
it so sacred that not even the Council's better judgment can override it?
Is this part of the "Jedi Code," unspecified in the film, that Yoda refers
to?
In the novelization, Terry
Brooks offers the explanation that Yoda himself disagrees with the assignment,
but the Council is so impressed at Kenobi's defeat of a Sith lord that
they think he's ready for anything. It's a little feeble.
In fact, the Council is
as helpless as Kenobi before the will of the Force. Kenobi's personal hubris
may only be a reflection of the appalling arrogance
of the entire Jedi order, and while the rest of them apparently perish,
he alone remains alive to tell the tale -- and suffer the brunt of the
Force's avenging fury.
So why does Yoda dissent?
We mustn't forget that even
if the Force is a providential deity, it still has a dark side. It seeks
balance, and many lives will be lost in that process; the dark side,
as we know, will have the upper hand for twenty-odd years during the Emperor's
reign.
Perhaps Yoda sees alternate
paths to balance that require less suffering.
Campbell and the Greeks
Many have argued that Anakin
Skywalker is a tragic figure.
Yet Anakin's journey is,
in the terms employed by George Lucas' mythic teacher Joseph
Campbell, not that of the tragic hero but that of the "eternal hero."
We are likely to see Anakin die when he purportedly falls into a
"molten pit" while battling Obi-Wan and then descend into hell,
spending 20 years behind Vader's mask as a slave to the dark side.
We have already seen his
resurrection
in the triumph over the Emperor and his ascension as a Force Ghost
at the end of The Return of the Jedi.
Obi-Wan's story follows
the alternate, pathos-ridden pattern of the tragic hero in the classical
Greek sense, and this makes it easier for us to shed a sympathetic tear
for poor old Ben while we revere and fear Anakin as the "Chosen One," the
"Son of Suns" and, in the first trilogy, as the Dark Lord of the Sith.
Lucas probably does not
intend for us to identify with Anakin except on a very figurative level
-- a hallmark of the Campbellian eternal hero -- whereas Obi-Wan fully
participates in the daily human condition we are all familiar with.
Flaws tragic in retrospect
However, it may not be that
easy to identify with Kenobi as a young man.
Some might protest that
his character is far from appealing in The Phantom Menace. Bullying
Jar Jar with threats of being "blahsted into oblivion", derisive comments
such as the infamous "pathetic life form" line, sulking when Qui-Gon Jinn
gives him the boot in favor of young Anakin, all render him somewhat antipathetic.
True to character, these
lines reverberate with the familiar "wretched hive of scum and villainy"
from A New Hope. Perhaps these are hints of hubris.
Or perhaps Lucas wanted
to portray him – possibly heavy-handedly – as all too human in order to
make him more endearing. He's a contrast to the wise, if cavalier, Qui-Gon,
and his imperfections may be an attempt to heighten the pathos when his
doom finally takes center stage.
Like Hollywood filmmakers,
Greek tragedians found it essential to make their stories grandiose (on
a galactic scale even, with respect to Lucas) yet accessible enough for
spectators to recognize themselves in the stories of heroic struggle. The
better we relate to Kenobi as grandiose everyman, the more effective the
tragedy.
The end of the story
If we can agree that George
Lucas -- notorious for his concern
with the forms and patterns of ancient and mythic drama -- is conscious
of these parallels, then Greek tragedy gives fans an enjoyable new platform
for speculation on what to expect in Episodes II and III.
Will we see Kenobi make
some explicitly fatal error with Anakin, misjudging the young Jedi's weaknesses
and precipitating the downfall of all?
What sort of ominous foreshadowing
will Lucas insinuate into Episode II? A training battle between Master
and Padawan, a seemingly insignificant argument that will lead to Vader's
sinister "I am the Master now"?
Will we hear from a "blind
prophet" character -- perhaps Plo Koon or some other weird Jedi -- to play
the part of the Greek Tiresias and foresee catastrophe?
Will the Force visit Kenobi
with vengeful "furies" (bounty hunters? Sith acolytes?) that pursue him
into exile in the wastes of Tatooine?
I'll be among the hoi
polloi camped out in front of a movie theater to find out.
"Phantom Heresies" will
run on SPACE.com until May 11, the first anniversary of Episode One's gala
premiere. The goal of the series is to refresh some fans and surprise others
through pointing out the film's hidden complexities, culminating in a full
appreciation of The Phantom Menace as ritual theatre.
Next: "Trash and Power on The Cutting Edge of the Old Republic".
What do you think? Send
your comments to the editor.