Creating
a money-making rationale for private space ventures--be they public space
travel, orbiting hotels, low-cost rocketry, a space junk collection service, or
even a lunar power and light company--such enterprises must be grounded in first-order
business basics.
Over
the decades, several entrepreneurial space firms have come and gone, their
vision getting too far ahead of business reality, but there are encouraging
signs that private space ventures are reinvigorating--as well as agitating and
disrupting--customary models of space commercialization.
That's
the message to be heard at Space Billionaires: Educating the Next Generation
of Entrepreneurs, a Thought Leader Forum being held April 4 at the Wilshire
Grand Hotel in Los Angeles and organized by the University of Southern
California's (USC) Marshall Center for Technology Commercialization.
Voodoo to mainstream science
"To
date the space industry has been focused on engineering and technology. Looking
into the future, the industry needs to think more creatively about developing
new business models for space," said Kathleen Allen, Director of the Marshall
Center for Technology Commercialization.
"Even the big companies realize that
the days of simply being a government contractor are changing. Everybody
needs to think more entrepreneurially," Allen told SPACE.com. She is also a professor
at USC's Lloyd Greif Center for Entrepreneurial Studies.
Allen
said that the private space industry is comprised of pioneers...leading-edge
entrepreneurs. "It's very analogous to what happened with nanotechnology," she
observed.
"Less
than 10 years ago, nanotechnology was voodoo science and the people who talked
about it were considered to be on the fringe of real science. Today
nanotechnology is mainstream science in the sense that everyone is talking
about it. I think the same thing is happening with space tourism and other
private space enterprise. Ten years from now, everyone will take it seriously
and believe that it can happen," Allen explained.
There
are messages that space entrepreneurs need to hear and be reminded of, Allen
emphasized.
For
one, don't be discouraged when people throw up roadblocks. Space entrepreneurs
are the visionaries, the disruptors--part of an emerging industry that
re-energized and revolutionized the entire space industry, she said.
Totally spaced out
"Space
business is just not about things in orbit or beyond," said Madhu Thangavelu,
who conducts the Graduate Space Concepts Studio at USC, a "visioneering"
approach to space systems architecting.
Thangavelu,
a forum discussant, said he sees "wonderful, thought provoking, awe inspiring
activities", a host of space-related businesses that can be executed here on
Earth.
But
just how out of whack are space entrepreneurial groups contrasted to
other entrepreneurial activities of the day. Or, are they in synch?
"Totally,
totally spaced out," Thangavelu advised. "Just being an entrepreneur is bad
enough."
For
comparison, look at the restaurant business, where three out of four
enterprises go belly up in two years from inception, Thangavelu noted.
Upstart startup
"Space
business needs to look at broader alternate futures, not just
high-tech rockets and their components...horribly expensive testing and failure
rates worse than restaurant business, not to mention all the regulation that
they ball and chain you to," he told SPACE.com.
The
recent launch failure suffered by upstart startup SpaceX, while a let down,
Thangavelu said that the firm has clearly established a lead in the business
and first mover advantage. He said there's need to invigorate the costly
pseudo-business model that exists now--"where the U.S. Air Force and NASA
are the customers and a bunch of privileged vendors called 'defense
contractors' pretend to compete."
"Space
enterprise is a highly creative, innovative and interdisciplinary arena,"
Thangavelu said. "We need new blood and a whole bunch of imaginative
people to project visions, debate ideas, present concepts--not just NASA
projects--and that will surely have the potential to make human space activity
richer, more interesting."
Heartfelt setbacks
"The
spontaneity of space is what gives the space entrepreneurs their
drive," said Rick Citron of the law firm Citron & Deutsch in Los
Angeles, a group that also serves, as they term it, an "entrepreneurial
greenhouse".
"Thinking
outside the box creates genius," Citron said, and being engaged in such
activity means not being prone to doing those things necessary to be in
alignment with anyone. Each of the 30-plus space enthusiast groups has their
own agenda, he told SPACE.com, "and that is a good thing for this
evolutionary process."
Are
other entrepreneurs similarly composed? "No, but many of them strive for
the gusto that comes from the process of controversial change," Citron
explained. He is also taking part in this week's forum.
Given
the recent woes experienced by SpaceX, does their failed rocket attempt to
reach orbit put a damper on things?
"Not
on your life," Citron responded. "Those of us who have lived 50-plus years of
the exploration of space have seen more than our share of heartfelt setbacks.
This was not a failure...we can't call it that. Rather, it was another step
towards the conquest of space."
Citron's
message to entrepreneurs: "The engineers and dreamers who are making these
things happen need to have a business team along their side. The business team
figures out the reality, what it takes to bring management and capital to the
table."
And
if the mix is right, Citron continued, that allows the inventors to create
financially viable products and services. "The right people will assist in translating
the dreams to allow others to participate in developing an environment for
success," he said.
For more information on
USC's Space Billionaires: Educating the Next Generation of Entrepreneurs
forum, go to: http://www.usc.edu/org/techalliance/Space2006_home.htm