Skip to main content

What if Earth shared its orbit with another planet?

Two Earth-like planets in space.
(Image: © Shutterstock)

The series "Imaginary Earths" speculates what the world might be like if one key aspect of life changed, be it related to the planet or with humanity itself.

Earth is the only planet traveling within its nearly circular orbit around the sun. But what if Earth shared its orbit with another planet? 

One of the most unusual ways in which two planets might "co-orbit," or share the same zone around their star, are so-called horseshoe orbits. Instead of both worlds moving in a circle around a star, each would move along the edge of their own somewhat horseshoe-shaped track, with these crescents facing each other like two halves of a broken ring.

Related: 10 interesting places in the solar system we'd like to visit

"I think horseshoe orbits are among the most exciting configurations for other Earths," astrophysicist Sean Raymond at the Laboratoire d'Astrophysique de Bordeaux in France, told Live Science. "Since the two planets formed in the same disk around the same star, and likely from similar stuff, studying their evolution is akin to studying the lives of twins separated at birth."

The horseshoe orbits of Saturn's moons Janus and Epimetheus.

The horseshoe orbits of Saturn's moons Janus and Epimetheus. (Image credit: Sean Raymond)

Horseshoe orbits might sound extraordinarily unlikely. However, Saturn's moons Janus and Epimetheus travel in horseshoe orbits about 93,000 miles (150,000 kilometers) from the planet, just beyond Saturn's main rings, Raymond noted. The closest they get is about 9,300 miles (15,000 km) from one another.

Let's imagine what horseshoe orbits might look like with a pair of Earth-size worlds in the sun's habitable zone — the area surrounding a star temperate enough for liquid water to survive on a planet's surface. Let's name these worlds Terra and Tellus, both Latin words for "Earth."

At their closest possible approach to each other, Terra and Tellus would come within about 4% to 5% of an astronomical unit (AU), the average distance between Earth and the sun (which is about 93 million miles, or 150 million kilometers). At such a distance, they would look as large to each other as one-quarter to one-fifth the diameter of the full moon, Raymond said. Afterwards, they would slowly recede away from each other until they passed out of sight of one another behind the sun.

"It would be awesome to see the horseshoe companion grow in the sky to become a dominant source of light," Raymond said.

The length of these cycles of approaches and departures depends on the width of the horseshoe orbits. For Terra and Tellus, the horseshoe orbits would extend from about 0.995 AU to about 1.005 AU, so it would take about 33 years between close encounters, Raymond said. The tiny shifts in distance from the sun would likely mean the climates of Terra and Tellus would not change much as they switch between sides of their horseshoe orbits, he noted.

What might life be like on Terra and Tellus? Raymond could imagine rivalries and partnerships between the planets, including wars and star-crossed love stories. One might also imagine that long before they launched missions to one another, these worlds might engage in long-distance pen pal relationships over radio.

Horseshoe Earths would likely evolve during the course of planetary formation as protoplanets, or embryonic worlds, both having collided and migrated from one orbit to another.

"Some fraction of the time, a horseshoe configuration will pop up," Raymond said. "Exactly how frequently this happens has never been studied carefully to my knowledge."

Still, "even if it's a one-in-a-million occurrence, that still leaves plenty of potential horseshoe Earths among the hundreds of billions of stars in the galaxy," Raymond concluded.

Originally published on Live Science.

Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions, night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at: community@space.com.

  • rod
    The article said "Let's imagine what horseshoe orbits might look like with a pair of Earth-size worlds in the sun's habitable zone — the area surrounding a star temperate enough for liquid water to survive on a planet's surface. Let's name these worlds Terra and Tellus, both Latin words for "Earth."

    Well this is intriguing. I have not seen horseshoe orbits described so far for any exoplanets confirmed, now more than 4300. I did a gravity force measurement comparison using the present Earth-Moon system and compared to twin Earths coming within 0.05 AU of each other (4 or 5% 1 AU). Present force for Earth-Moon system at 60.3 earth radii is about 1.983E+25 dynes cm^2 s^1. The worlds Terra and Tellus coming within 0.05 AU and similar in earth mass experience 4.25E+24 dynes cm^2 s^-1. So would Terra and Tellus be a stable orbit over long time spans?

    Interesting, horseshoe shaped orbits :) One more item from this report. "The length of these cycles of approaches and departures depends on the width of the horseshoe orbits. For Terra and Tellus, the horseshoe orbits would extend from about 0.995 AU to about 1.005 AU, so it would take about 33 years between close encounters, Raymond said. The tiny shifts in distance from the sun would likely mean the climates of Terra and Tellus would not change much as they switch between sides of their horseshoe orbits, he noted."

    It would seem Terra and Tellus every 33 years would undergo a mutual force of gravity measurement change on the two bodies. That would need to be considered, e.g. increased volcanic activity? Io at Jupiter is an example.
    Reply
  • GreatDarkSpot
    Well, then we wouldn't be living on a planet since it wouldn't have 'cleared it's orbit' (eyeroll).
    Reply