Alice Gorman (opens in new tab), Associate Professor in Archaeology and Space Studies, Flinders University
On October 5, an unusual crew will fly to the International Space Station. Director Klim Shipenko and actor Yulia Peresild will spend a week and a half on the station shooting scenes for the Russian movie Challenge (opens in new tab). Peresild plays a surgeon who must conduct a heart operation on a sick cosmonaut.
This is an exciting — if controversial — development for the station, which orbits around 250 miles (400 kilometers) above Earth. Commercial use of its facilities could be a funding avenue (opens in new tab) to keep it in orbit. A Japanese documentary (opens in new tab) and an American movie starring Tom Cruise (opens in new tab) are also in the works.
The station consists of 16 modules locked together in a cross configuration. There are six Russian modules in the Russian Orbital Segment, while the U.S. Orbital Segment consists of 11 modules run by the U.S., Japan, and the European Space Agency. Spacecraft like the Russian Soyuz and SpaceX's Dragon regularly dock with the station to bring crew and supplies and return others to Earth.
Usually there are between three and six crew living on the station. The main work is scientific experiments, but as some parts of the station are over 20 years old, a lot of maintenance is also required.
Space stations in the movies are often very "space-agey" with futuristic minimalist interiors. By contrast, the International Space Station is a mess, more "Red Dwarf" than "2001: A Space Odyssey." There are cables everywhere, walls cluttered with equipment, tools, food packages and notes, and over 6,000 objects lost by the crew.
"Challenge," being the first (professional (opens in new tab)) space movie to be filmed in space, raises a number of questions. Here are five on my mind.
How will the cosmonaut crew react to a female 'space tourist?'
After Valentina Tereshkova, the first woman in space in 1963, only four other Russian women have ever left Earth.
Svetlana Savitskaya was the second female cosmonaut in 1982. Her crewmates on the Mir space station presented her with an apron (opens in new tab) when she arrived, joking that she'd work in the kitchen. I’ve even heard a cosmonaut trainer say "space is no place for a woman."
However, in Russia, medicine is seen as a female profession (opens in new tab). Given that veteran cosmonaut Sergei Krikalev was sacked for objecting to the movie plans (he was later reinstated), I'm wondering what Yulia Peresild's reception will be like.
What about using the space toilets?
Personal hygiene is challenging in the microgravity environment of the space station. Crew must be taught how to use the complicated space toilets, which use vacuum pumps to suck everything away from the body and into tanks. Urine is recycled to augment the station's water supply — as the joke goes, yesterday's coffee becomes tomorrow's coffee.
Then there's the politics of space poo. In 2009, strained relationships between Moscow and Washington resulted in Russian and U.S. crews being banned (opens in new tab) from using each other's toilets. Crew complained that not being able to use the nearest toilet interrupted their work.
Peresild and Shipenko have been training since May in Russia's Star City (opens in new tab), and this presumably includes potty-training too. NASA only installed the first female-friendly toilet (opens in new tab) in 2020.
In the Russian segment where the filming will take place, there's one old toilet designed for male anatomy. In female bodies, there's less separation between pee and poo, so NASA designed its new toilet to take this into account. Will Peresild use the NASA toilet by preference? She'll be the first Russian woman to compare space toilet technology.
How realistic will the surgery scenes be?
In space, uncontained liquids form bubbles and float around. This presents some challenges for heart surgery, especially as blood tends to pool in the upper parts of the body. There have been limited surgical experiments (opens in new tab) already in microgravity, but they have been done on artificial bodies, or animals such as rats.
Technology under development for future space missions, particularly long-duration flights like those to Mars, includes robotic surgery and capsules that enclose the patient, with the surgeon operating on them through arm portholes. It will be interesting to see what choices are made to portray this key part of the film.
Read more: From floating guts to 'sticky' blood – here's how to do surgery in space (opens in new tab)
Will the film crew leave anything behind in space?
As a space archaeologist, I'm interested in whether this unusual activity will contribute to the archaeological record of the station. While the film crew will have to bring all their equipment with them, scientific experiments are prioritized due to limited cargo space when sending things back to Earth. Later crew may find objects left behind by Peresild and Shipenko, stuck to Velcro patches on the walls or lurking in storage areas.
In the Russian Zvezda module, cosmonauts have made part of a wall into an informal gallery or shrine. Analysis of how the pictures displayed change over time (opens in new tab) shows it almost always features images of the Soviet space heroes Yuri Gagarin, Konstantin Tsiolkovsky and Sergei Korolev, as well as Russian Orthodox icons.
Peresild's father is a well-known icon painter, so perhaps she will bring one to contribute to this display.
What happens next?
After this flight, Peresild and Shipenko will officially be space travelers, as well as the first professional filmmakers in space. They'll join the ranks of an elite group who've travelled into orbit.
Although the last year has seen numerous people who have just nudged into space on suborbital flights, including Jeff Bezos, Richard Branson and the "civilian" Inspiration4 crew, it still means something to actually live in space.
At least 45 films about space travel have received Oscar nominations for Best Visual Effects (opens in new tab), but in the case of "Challenge," the visual effects will be real.
Perhaps this will be a turning point in how space habitats are depicted in films. Will audiences prefer the glamorous fantasy, or replace their visions of future space travel with the gritty reality of a working space station?
Follow all of the Expert Voices issues and debates — and become part of the discussion — on Facebook and Twitter. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.