'Forbidden Planet' is one of the most influential sci-fi films of all time, and it's getting a remake

Forbidden Planet
(Image credit: Warner Bros)

In the realm of retro science fiction cinema, "Forbidden Planet" is unanimously considered a Hollywood classic and ranks at the top of almost any serious list of seminal outer space films. This 1956 retelling of William Shakespeare's "The Tempest" proudly stands amid the company of other vintage works like "The Thing From Another World," "Invasion of the Body Snatchers," "The War of the Worlds," and "The Day the Earth Stood Still" as prime examples of that long-past Golden Age.

Of that celebrated group of 1950s sci-fi movies, "Forbidden Planet" also remains the only one that has mercifully not received a Tinseltown reboot, but that's all about to change with recent news of a Warner Bros. "revisionist" remake in the works from Eisner Award-winning comic book creator and screenwriter Brian K. Vaughan ("Y: The Last Man," "Saga") and seasoned producer Emma Watts.

As reported last week by Deadline, Vaughan will pen the script for an updated take on "Forbidden Planet" much to the dismay of purists who believe the material should be left untouched regardless of his solid reputation as a gifted storyteller.

A vintage MGM lobby card for 1956's "Forbidden Planet." (Image credit: MGM)

"Forbidden Planet" was originally directed by Fred M. Wilcox and starred Walter Pidgeon, Leslie Nielsen, and Anne Francis. It was loosely adapted from The Bard's final completed stage play about marooned sailors on a magical island lorded over by a sorcerer named Prospero — an interesting plot that was revamped into a grand galactic adventure where a crew from the patrol spaceship C-57D lands on the planet Altair IV to investigate a colony of forgotten scientists. 

Warned to stay away by its genius sole survivor Dr. Morbius (Pidgeon) and his daughter Altaira (Francis), Commander John Adams (Nielsen) and Co. arrive in spite of the dangers to discover an invisible murderous monster prowling the planet and uncover the mystery of a long-perished alien civilization who've left their advanced technology behind. And let's not forget 'ol Robby the Robot!

Vaughan is certainly up to the task of composing a competent screenplay for a "Forbidden Planet" remake. His comic book projects also include "Ex Machina," "Runaways," "Pride of Baghdad," and "Paper Girls," and in Hollywood, Vaughan has been attached to hit TV series such as "Lost," where he acted as writer, story editor, and producer for three seasons before being anointed by the legendary Steven Spielberg to bring Stephen King's "Under the Dome" to the small screen in 2013.

Earthly astronauts meet Dr. Morbius and Robby the Robot in "Forbidden Planet" (Image credit: MGM)

But as the old adage goes, simply because something CAN be done does not necessarily mean that it SHOULD be done, and many restless fans would be perfectly content to leave "Forbidden Planet" untainted and unaltered forever.

Bringing her considerable experience with major tentpole releases while serving as the head of 20th Century Fox's and Paramount's feature film divisions on sci-fi flicks like "I, Robot," "Alita: Battle Angel," "The Martian," "Maze Runner" and "Avatar," Watts is a powerhouse producer that could just pull off the Herculean task of conjuring up more Hollywood magic here. This big-budget remake is still in its infancy but we'll keep our readers in the loop as it continues to move forward towards reality.

Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions, night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at: community@space.com.

Jeff Spry
Contributing Writer

Jeff Spry is an award-winning screenwriter and veteran freelance journalist covering TV, movies, video games, books, and comics. His work has appeared at SYFY Wire, Inverse, Collider, Bleeding Cool and elsewhere. Jeff lives in beautiful Bend, Oregon amid the ponderosa pines, classic muscle cars, a crypt of collector horror comics, and two loyal English Setters.

  • Viking
    Won't miss it, won't see it but won't miss it.
    Reply
  • Helio
    That was one of the greatest sci-fi movies ever made.

    I was curious about a rough release date, but couldn't find anything.

    Surprisingly, I did see this....

    "James Cameron was once set to direct a remake of Forbidden Planet. The project was in the works at Warner Bros in the 2010s, but never materialised. J Michael Straczynski was assigned to write a script and recently took to X/Twitter to talk about what happened.

    “It’s maddening that right now, just sitting on a shelf at Warners, is a really solid screenplay for a FORBIDDEN PLANET movie, written by me, from a story by me and James Freaking Cameron. It’s production-ready, you can just drop it on the stage and shoot it,” Straczynski replied to another tweet."

    Avatar
    seems to have prevented the production.

    here]
    Reply
  • Meteoric Marmot
    I don't see a way to improve on near perfection. If you want to make a different SF movie based on The Tempest, sure, have at it. Reworking Forbidden Planet sounds like it's doomed to failure. I'll wait to see how it does if it ever gets to fruition, but I'm not hopeful.
    Reply
  • EJD1984
    Personally I have always been hopeful for the J. Michael Straczynski take on Forbidden Planet.
    Would have been a trilogy, with FB as the middle movie. The twist would have been Altaris Morbius was the real ID villain, and the third movie would have brought her to Earth.
    Reply
  • Marc2001
    When seeing the special effects in the original, it's hard to believe that movie was made almost 70 years ago!
    Reply
  • Unclear Engineer
    Well, I expect that the vintage "Robbie the Robot" will get an update, at least.

    And there will probably be an "AI" theme to it. Perhaps the alien species died because their AI misinterpreted their priorities, over-animating their IDs darker thoughts without balancing it with the other parts of their personas. A fundamental programming error in a too-powerful tool.

    But, the way Hollywood has been going recently, I think EJD1984 is likely to be correct that they will try to milk it for all (more than ?) it is worth, by making it a franchise "world", with ever-increasing numbers of releases and spin-offs, tending to degrade into the "aliens invade Earth" theme with too much "action" scenes and to little real thought provoking content.
    Reply
  • GregB03
    I'm going to have to see what happens to the remake before saying much about it. The Krell machine was kind of like an nth-generation internet. When the Krell machine went operational the Krell went extinct in what must have been the mother of all flame wars. All the creation by mere thought must have maxed out the available bandwidth and caused unacceptable levels of buffering and net congestion leading to the flame war.
    Reply
  • Unclear Engineer
    LOL
    Reply