Europe Lays Down the Law for New Space Lab

Europe Lays Down the Law for New Space Lab
An artist's impression of Columbus, a cutaway view, the European laboratory module of the International Space Station. Credits: ESA - D.Ducros

Ifastronauts onboard the International Space Station (ISS) run afoul of the law morethan 200 miles (321 kilometers) above Earth, their fate usually depends on wherein the orbital lab the incident occurred.

That legal framework will become a bit more complicated whena new European Space Agency (ESA) module becomes part of ISS this month.

The spacestation currently exists as a legal patchwork of about 16 sovereign territories– modules and hardware belonging to the United States, Russia, Canada, Europeand Japan – joined together to form one orbital research platform. Each nationhas legal authority over its part of the space station, as stated in the OuterSpace Treaty of 1967. But no single European nation's law will hold sway overthe ESA'sColumbus laboratory module, which is slated to launch into orbit aboard thespaceshuttle Atlantis Dec. 6, and there is no one overarching European law.

However, astronautlawbreakers won't languish in limbo. Earlier this year, European legal expertsagreed on a set of legal rules for Columbus during an conference entitled "Humans in Outer Space – Interdisciplinary Odysseys."

Shouldtempers flare and astronauts end up in fisticuffs inside Columbus, the perpetrator's fate would bedecided by the criminal laws of his or her nation. But if the brawl occurred inan American, Russian or Japanese section of ISS, the perpetrator's fate couldbe decided by the criminal laws of his or her victim's nation.

"Theydecided that if somebody performs an activity which may be considered criminal,it is in the first instance his own country which is able to exercisejurisdiction," saidFrans von der Dunk, of the International Institute of Air and Space Law at the University of Leiden, in a written statement.

Althoughastronauts are an exceptionally well-behaved group, other legal concerns mayarise. An invention created by an enterprising astronaut on ISS will bepatented in the nation that has jurisdiction over the module where work tookplace, not the nation of the inventor. Innovators onboard Columbus will have a choice of patentingtheir work in either Germany or Italy – although European patent agreements make this distinctionless important.

Civilliability on the space station is another issue. If someone on Earth gets hitby a car, they can sue the offending driver. If astronauts accidentally damage equipmentin Columbus while doing their usual duties onthe space station, they typically don't have to fear a lawsuit.

"Weare all there together, we all have the same purpose to make the ISS into a bigsuccess and we don't want that attitude, that mentality, to be disturbed by thethreat of one party suing the other," von der Dunk said.

The ESAdecision follows a previous cross-waiver agreement that the spirit ofinternational cooperation is more important than minor legal squabbling. When asolararray on the space station ripped during space shuttle Discovery's missionin October, the involved astronauts and agencies simply planned and executed arepair job instead of pointing fingers.

But"there are a number of exceptions" to the cross-waiver for civilliability, noted Andre Farand, a senior administrator in ESA's legal department,in an e-mail interview. For instance, injury or death suffered byindividual astronauts could still lead to legal claims against the organizationwhich caused the harm.

What murkyareas remain in space law may come from the growing presence of privateinterests, whether through space tourism or even astronauts participating in commercialactivities on ISS, said Farand. For the few space tourists who have visitedISS, Russia proposed the legal rules that otherISS partners then reviewed and agreed on, according to NASA's legal department.

TheEuropean Columbus laboratory will launch toward theISS aboard NASA's shuttle at Atlantis on Dec. 6 at 4:31 p.m. EST (2131 GMT). Click here for's shuttle launch coverage and liveNASA TV feed.

  • VIDEO: ISS Commander Peggy Whitson Takes Charge
  • NEW IMAGES: Discovery's STS-120 Mission in Pictures
  • The Orbital Chef: The Top 10 Space Foods

Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions, night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at:

Contributing Writer

Jeremy Hsu is science writer based in New York City whose work has appeared in Scientific American, Discovery Magazine, Backchannel, and IEEE Spectrum, among others. He joined the and Live Science teams in 2010 as a Senior Writer and is currently the Editor-in-Chief of Indicate Media.  Jeremy studied history and sociology of science at the University of Pennsylvania, and earned a master's degree in journalism from the NYU Science, Health and Environmental Reporting Program. You can find Jeremy's latest project on Twitter