NASA has directed Boeing to throttle back on
development of the orbital variant of the X-37 prototype space plane until more
money is found for the program, an action likely to delay a re-entry and landing
demonstration that was planned for 2006.
The purpose of the X-37 program is to validate new
technologies in space and test system performance during orbit, re-entry and
landing. NASA says the results of the X-37 flight will aid in the development of
the Orbital Space Plane, an expendable-rocket-launched vehicle the agency wants
to field by 2008 to serve as a crew lifeboat for the international space
station.
NASA officials will not specify how much more money
is needed to carry through with the orbital flight, saying only that the $178
million budgeted for the program for 2004 is not enough to both finish an
atmospheric test version of the winged X-37 and proceed with work on a separate
vehicle designed to go into space.
Daniel Dumbacher, NASA’s X-37 program manager, said
Boeing officials were told in late November to concentrate on finishing the
atmospheric test vehicle in time for a drop test from an aircraft in late 2004.
Although Boeing also was told to continue work on some of the high-risk
technologies needed for the orbital X-37, design work on that vehicle is on
hold, he said.
NASA plans had called for launching the orbital
vehicle in 2006 on either an Atlas 5 or Delta 4 expendable rocket for a 270-day
orbital mission, after which it would re-enter the atmosphere and glide in for
an aircraft-like landing. Dumbacher said that demonstration will be delayed, but
could not say for how long. He said NASA has no plans to scrap the orbital
flight.
But officials with Boeing NASA Systems, Huntington
Beach, Calif., say it is not entirely clear what the future holds for the X-37
program.
Paul Geery, Boeing’s X-37 program manager, said the
company has a “reasonable commitment” but “not a strong commitment” from NASA
that the orbital vehicle will be built. For that reason, he said, the company
cannot afford to press on with development work on the orbital vehicle while
NASA works out the funding issues.
“If there was a guaranteed order in the works, it
would be no problem,” Geery said in an interview. “But we are still in the
negotiation phase of whether we restart” in 2004 or 2005, he said. “It’s just a
little too unclear for us to make a commitment.”
Geery said Boeing intends to reassign about 100 of
the roughly 400 engineers working on the X-37 to other programs within the
company by the end of February. Most of Boeing’s X-37 jobs are in Huntington
Beach, Calif., with the rest in Palmdale, Calif.
Geery said the cost of the X-37 atmospheric test
vehicle has grown, but would not say by how much. He attributed the cost growth
to a number of factors, including a several-month delay in getting under
contract in 2002 and the need to strengthen X-37’s wings. Geery said that
redesign effort is complete.
NASA’s involvement in the X-37 dates back to 1998,
when the project was selected as the first of a planned series of flight
demonstrators dubbed Future X. At the time, NASA agreed to share the X-37’s
projected $173 million cost with Boeing and the U.S. Air Force. After the Air
Force announced in 2001 that it would stop funding the project, NASA told Boeing
that the company would have to submit a new proposal for X-37 to be eligible for
additional funding.
After persistent prodding from U.S. Rep. Dana
Rohrabacher (R-Calif.), NASA in 2002 awarded Boeing a $301 million contract for
two vehicles instead of one. One of those vehicles would conduct a a series of
drop tests within the atmosphere, paving the way for the flight of the orbit and
re-entry vehicle in 2006.
NASA determined earlier this year that the X-37
orbital vehicle had grown to a projected weight of 5,400 kilograms — too heavy
to launch on a Delta 2 rocket as planned. The decision was then made to launch
the craft aboard the heavy-lift variant of either the Delta 4 or Atlas 5, both
of which are far more powerful but also far more expensive than the Delta
2.
More recently, NASA asked Boeing to design the X-37
orbital vehicle for a 270-day stay on orbit. NASA and Boeing were negotiating a
contract modification to cover that requirement when NASA decided to put the
orbital vehicle on the back burner.
Dumbacher said NASA is seeking additional money for
the X-37 as part of a supplemental budget request for 2004 that the agency is
pushing primarily to accelerate the Orbital Space Plane program by two years. He
declined to specify how much money NASA is seeking, saying the funding outlook
for both programs should be clearer by the time the White House sends its 2005
spending request to Congress in February.
A NASA source said a supplemental request that
includes funds for the X-37 and Orbital Space Plane has been sent to the White
House Office of Management and Budget.
Because the U.S. Senate adjourned for the year
without approving an omnibus spending bill that would fund NASA in 2004, the
White House could still amend its request to add more money for the Orbital
Space Plane program. But such an action would entail sending the $328 billion
spending package back to the House, which approved the measure Dec.
8.
A NASA supplemental could be included next year in
one of the emergency spending bills Congress passes nearly every year to pay for
U.S. military engagements and disaster relief. Congress also could attach a NASA
supplemental to another unrelated bill. In July, for example, Congress added $50
million to help pay for Columbia disaster recovery operations to the legislative
branch spending bill.