The following details of the
new idea were provided by Benny Peiser and Michael Paine and appear here with
only minimal editing for style and clarity:
The findings are calculated on the basis of the
generally accepted "impact rate" (i.e. the rate of cosmic impacts calculated
from terrestrial and lunar impact craters together with the currently observable
flux of asteroids and comets in the solar system). A computer simulation of
cosmic impacts over a 5 million-year period was chosen to give an indication
of the environmental disruptions that have occurred during the evolution of
our species.
These consequences can be categorized into:
A. Local -- devastation over a radius of
tens of (miles) kilometers. No serious regional or global consequences
B. Moderate regional -- devastation over
a radius of hundreds of miles (kilometers) -- the size of a small country. Short-term
regional climatic problems.
C. Severe regional -- devastation over 600
miles (1,000 kilometers) (the size of a large country). Severe regional climatic
disruption. Mild, short-term global climatic disruption -- year without summer.
D. Moderate global -- devastation over thousands
of miles (kilometers) -- continental. Severe global climate disruption lasting
several years. Global food chain failures
E. Severe global -- global firestorms from
ballistic entry of impact debris. Extreme worldwide climate disruption for decades
to centuries. Extinctions.
For everything except the last category, the effects
on early human populations depend on proximity to the impact -- a matter of
luck. In addition to climate disruption (mainly darkness and cooling), the larger
impacts could lead to global warming due to the greenhouse effect (water and
carbon dioxide), loss of the ozone layer (particularly with ocean impacts that
propel chlorine into the upper atmosphere), acid rain and toxins.
The simulation looked at the worst event
in each of 5,000 millennia. It therefore gives an underestimate of the
total number of impacts.
The program recognizes five outcomes of an asteroid
or comet colliding with Earth:
- The object skims the atmosphere and flies harmlessly
back into space. This happened in 2 percent of the millennia.
- The object explodes above land in an airburst
similar to an atomic explosion. This happened in 17 percent of the millennia.
- The object impacts the land and forms a crater.
This happened in 11 percent of the millennia.
- The object explodes in an airburst above an
ocean. This was the most frequent outcome, accounting for 41 percent of millennia.
Fortunately, until recently, most of these impacts would have been harmless
to land dwelling creatures.
- The object impacts the ocean, forming tsunami
and, possibly, ejecting vast quantities of water and salt into the atmosphere.
This happened in 28 percent of the millennia. (Larger impacts may also reach
the ocean floor and cause similar effects to a land impact)
Over the period of the simulation some 57 percent
of millennia suffered an impact that would potentially have consequences for
land-dwelling creatures. In most cases they would only be affected when they
were close to the impact site. The situation is different now with significant
human populations living in low-lying coastal areas.
Size impactor (The letters refer to the
typical environmental consequences.)
1,650 to 2,950 feet (500 to 900 meters) (C): 108
events
0.6 to 0.9 miles (1 to 1.5 kilometers) (C/D): 24
events
1 mile (1.6 kilometers +) (D/E): 13 events
Craters (The letters refer to the typical
environmental consequences.)
Over the 5,000 millennia a total of 552 craters
were formed on land. Of these:
- 477 were less than 3 miles (5 kilometers) in
diameter (A);
- 64 were between 3 and 6 miles (5 and 10 kilometers)
in diameter (B);
- nine were between 6 and 12 miles (10 and 20
kilometers) in diameter (C);
- two were more than 12 miles (20 kilometers)
(D).
There were also six ocean impacts that could be
expected to produce moderate-to-severe global climate disruption (D/E), particularly
destruction of the ozone layer. Three of these involved transient craters more
than 31 miles (50 kilometers) in diameter and would probably have penetrated
to the ocean floor.
Therefore, during this simulation severe climate
disruption occurred, on average, every million years (i.e., two land impacts
and three ocean impacts).
The findings by Peiser and Paine are underpinned
by a significant number of large impact craters. So far, 32 impact craters have
been discovered that are younger than 5 million years. One is 32 miles (52 kilometers)
in diameter, three are between 6 and 12 miles (10 and 20 kilometers), one is
between 3 and 6 miles (5 and 10 kilometers) and 25 are less than 3 miles (5
kilometers) in diameter. However, it should be noted that it takes very unusual
conditions to preserve craters of this size for more than a few hundred thousand
years.
Additional
background material is provided by the authors here.
Click
here for more news and information about asteroids and
their dangers.