The agents investigate two identical-looking women who seem to wreak havoc whenever they are near each other.
(originally aired May 7, 2000)
| A Way With People |
| Mulder: Are you a practitioner of the occult, Miss Templeton? Wicca? Voodoo? Satanism? The black art of bodily bi-location?Betty Templeton: Me? No. You know what they say, everyone has a twin out there somewhere.Mulder: No. We don't know what they say. |
Written by Chris Carter
Directed by Paul Shapiro
 |
 |
 |  | More Stories |
|  |
 | |  |
 | |  |
 | |  |
 | |  |
 |  | Related Links |
|  |
 |
|  |
 |
WHAT HAPPENED
A suburban street. Two young men in white shirts and dark ties are on bicycles. They go to a house that has a red car in the driveway, and try to give religious literature to a woman who answers the door. She’s not interested, helpfully explaining that she just moved in and is waiting for the cable guy. She shuts the door.
The missionaries bike over to another house -- this one differentiated by the presence of a blue car in the driveway -- and are surprised when an identical woman answers. Told that someone who looks just like her lives nearby, she gets upset, closes the door, paces.
Out front, the two young men suddenly turn and fight each other with mindless fury. (more
spoilers)
ANALYSIS
This episode conveys a strong sense of a writer, director and actors merely going through the motions, collecting their sizable paychecks while running out the clock on the season and series. The plot is not compelling, the agents themselves seem not to take it seriously, and the doppelgangers around whom the action revolves are little more than ciphers.
Having said all that, "Fight Club" still has to be regarded as better than some recent episodes, such as "
First Person Shooter," which were genuinely bad rather than just, as in the current case, mediocre. And this episode provides the oddly satisfying spectacle of "Mulder and Scully" pummeling each other.
[Editor's Note: Kenneth Silber was so irritated by the inclusion of doppelganger versions of our favorite agents -- likely a gesture toward thematic unity and/or irony on Chris Carter's part -- that he refuses to dignify the plot point with comment.]
WHAT WE LEARN
Perhaps needless to say, "Fight Club" does not further the series’ neglected "
mythology arc" of aliens, conspiracies and the like. However, one does detect, in Scully's lack of intellectual rigor here, a certain continuity from the recent episode "all things," in which she seemed to cast rationalism aside.
DANGLING PLOT THREADS
Will the doppelganger women find a way to disentangle themselves from their hurtful link to one another?
REALITY CHECK
The phenomenon depicted lacks an interesting mystical explanation, let alone a plausible scientific one.
TUNE IN NEXT WEEK
What if someone could make your wishes come true? Would it be a blessing -- or a nightmare? Find out in "Je Souhaite."
What do you think? Send your comments to the
long-suffering critic or editor.