Ad Astra OnlineLiveScience.com HomepageStarryNight.comtelescope.com
  SEARCH:

advertisement


TV Review: Star Trek: Voyager - 'Barge of the Dead'
By Kenneth Silber

Staff Writer

posted: 07:16 pm ET
22 March 2000

TV Review: Star Trek: Voyager - 'Barge of the Dead'

B'Elanna goes to the Klingon netherworld to restore her mother's honor -- and boost her own self-esteem.

(original air date October 6, 1999)

Quotable Moments
Tom [to B'Elanna]: One minute, you're in a coma. The next, you're a born-again Klingon. I don't get it.

Chakotay: I accept that there are things in this universe that can't be scanned with a tricorder.

Barge guard: The mongrel child has returned.

   More Stories

Star Trek: Voyager -- Seasons Six and Seven


Star Trek: Voyager - 'Tinker, Tenor, Doctor, Spy'


TV Review: Star Trek: Voyager - 'Survival Instinct'


TV Review: Star Trek: Voyager - 'Equinox'

   Related Links

Star Trek


Klingon Embassy


UPN

Written by Ronald D. Moore and Bryan Fuller
Directed by Mike Vejar

ADDITIONAL CREDITS

Eric Pierpoint -- Kotar

WHAT HAPPENED

B'Elanna is in a shuttle. There is some turbulence, and she calls for help, but soon she is safely aboard Voyager. Meanwhile, she finds a small plaque with a Klingon insignia -- a strange discovery, given that the Klingon Empire is on the other side of the galaxy. But things get stranger yet. Alone in her quarters, she observes blood spilling from the plaque, and hears a burst of noise and Klingon shouting.

After a tired Harry nonchalantly dismisses B'Elanna's experience, Neelix announces that he'll throw a party to celebrate recovery of the Klingon relic. B'Elanna is not enthused.... (more extensive spoilers)

ANALSIS

Like its titular slow boat, the "Barge of the Dead" carries viewers into a half-baked mishmash of New Age religious sentiment and self-actualization flapdoodle.

The Klingon netherworld jibes poorly with the complex but comprehensible universe that's generally been posited in Star Trek. The barge and its destination are reminiscent of classical and Christian visions of the afterlife, reflecting a lack of scriptwriting imagination.

B'Elanna's descent, in any event, turns out to be merely an opportunity for her to feel better about herself. No hard choices must be made. Eternal damnation lasts about 60 seconds.

Don't suffer through this one.

DANGLING PLOT THREADS

The Klingon artifact initially seems to be the cause of B'Elanna's netherworld experience. But then it seems to be a mere figment of that experience. Which is it?

REALITY CHECK

Oxygen deprivation may be the crucial factor in "near-death experiences" including afterlife visions. B'Elanna's experience also occurs amid reduced oxygen intake, but the script implies that genuine supernatural forces are at work as well.

TUNE IN NEXT WEEK

Reruns continue, but the lucky episode has yet to be announced.


What do you think? Send your comments to the author or editor.


     about us | FREE Email Newsletter | message boards | register at SPACE.com | contact us | advertise with us | terms & conditions | privacy policy      DMCA/Copyright

     © Imaginova Corp. All rights reserved.