Ad Astra OnlineLiveScience.com HomepageStarryNight.comtelescope.com
  SEARCH:

advertisement


Stargate SG-1 Skates Up Steep 'Learning Curve'
By Michael Bender

Special to space.com

posted: 04:46 pm ET
27 April 2000

TV Review: Stargate SG-1 - 'Learning Curve'

Jack tries to teach a very serious alien girl the joys of childhood.

(originally aired July 23, 1999)

The Notebooks of Jack O'Neill
O'Neill: General, for a few hours today I got to show that little girlhow to be a kid. If you want to punish me, go ahead.

O'Neill: General, she is going back to get her brain sucked out. And Idare anyone to phrase it more delicately.

Jackson: So when you say he gave you his knowledge, you meant it literally.

   More Stories

Stargate SG-1 - 'Learning Curve' (spoilers)


TV Review: Stargate SG-1 - 'Foothold'


TV Review: Stargate SG-1 - 'The Devil You Know'


TV Review: Stargate SG-1 - 'Jolinar's Memories'

   Related Links

Stargate SG-1 [official]

WHAT HAPPENED

In what appears to be an archaeological dig, many children dressed in white garb and turbans busily clean a ruin under the tutelage of one Daniel Jackson.

A nearby Stargate suddenly activates with its tell-tale "water jet" effect and Teal'C and Jack O'Neill walk through. Looking around, O'Neill makes a crack about child labor laws, but Jackson explains that the children are "Urrone" -- a type of apprentice on this planet, Orban -- and goes on about his recent discoveries.

The only adult in the Orbanian group, a pleasant-looking fellow named Kalin, then shows up, followed by a young girl carrying a small box. Kalin offers to exchange information on the alien Goa'uld with O'Neill and Teal'C, who agree to take him back with them to Earth.

The group returns to meet General Hammond and Samantha Carter back at Stargate Command. The girl gives the box -- an Orbanian reactor -- to Carter, an act which completes the exchange of information as far as Kalin is concerned.

When Carter protests that she needs some one to teach her about this technology, Kalin seems confused by the whole concept of teaching, but Marin (the young girl) volunteers her help.... (more spoilers)

ANALYSIS

On the surface, this was a well-paced and moving episode that stood on its own quite nicely. The use of children as a commodified resource inspired the anger in my stomach and lump in my throat that the series' creators were undoubtedly hoping to evoke.

I also found the passing of Merin’s knowledge of play to the other children to be quite touching, but the feeling didn't last long before I started thinking about how viable this would be.

First, Urrone children don’t receive nanites from their colleagues who undergo the Ovarium, so how could they learn from Marin's experience?

Moreover, I find it difficult to accept that it takes millions of nanites to help a Urrone learn, but just one to pass that information on to other Urrone -- or why the creators of this technology seemed to consider brain damage to be an acceptable side effect of the process.

Otherwise, the episode was good so long as the viewer can manage to suspend disbelief. I wish the writers would have done their research more diligently and thought through the ramifications of their alien devices a bit more thoroughly.

TUNE IN NEXT WEEK

Rerun season for SG-1 continues with "Pretense". The ultra-advanced alien Tollan summon the SG-1 team to help determine whether Skaara -- Daniel's brother-in-law -- should be freed of the Goa'uld parasite inside him.



What do you think? Send your comments to the editor.


     about us | FREE Email Newsletter | message boards | register at SPACE.com | contact us | advertise with us | terms & conditions | privacy policy      DMCA/Copyright

     © Imaginova Corp. All rights reserved.